Lime Replacements Under Test: What New Bond Strength Results Mean for Australian Bricklayers

Mortar testing

Hydrated lime has been part of Australian mortar for generations. On a growing number of sites, it has been replaced by powdered and liquid additives that promise the same workability with less handling. The question the industry keeps asking is a simple one: do these products hold up structurally?

 

Think Brick Australia LogoThink Brick Australia has now published the third phase of its testing program with TAFE NSW, and it is the most controlled phase yet. MERCOL was one of the mortar systems tested. Below we cover what the results show, where their limits are, and what they mean for anyone mixing mortar on site.

Why lime replacements are under the spotlight

Two pressures have pushed the trade away from hydrated lime. Sand quality has become more variable, which makes workability harder to achieve with a traditional mix, and hydrated lime carries real handling and safety concerns. Admixtures and lime replacement products have filled the gap.

 

The catch is that their performance depends heavily on the product, the dose and how the mortar is mixed. Phases 1 and 2 of the Think Brick program found a consistent pattern: overdosing and prolonged mixing generally reduced mortar performance, and some products with water-repellent properties were harder to clean off the brick face. Variability in workmanship, however, made it difficult to say how large the strength reductions really were. Phase 3 was designed to close that gap.

How the Phase 3 testing was run

  • Twenty stack-bonded prisms were built at TAFE NSW Granville on a single day in May 2026, with carefully controlled bed joints to reduce workmanship variation.

  • Five mortar systems were compared: a traditional M3 control mix with hydrated lime, a powdered lime replacement (XLime), a liquid lime replacement (GIBCO Liquid Lime) at both the recommended 40 mL dose and a deliberately overdosed 60 mL, and MERCOL pre-blended mortar.

  • The same off-white cement and the same bricklayer’s sand were used across the mixes.

  • Flexural bond strength was measured with a bond wrench to AS 3700 Appendix D by NATA-accredited laboratory Mahaffey Associates, at 7 and 29 days.

Average strength versus characteristic strength

One detail matters more than any single number in the results. AS 3700 requires masonry to achieve a characteristic flexural bond strength of at least 0.20 MPa at 7 days. A characteristic value is not an average. It is calculated from the weaker end of the test results, so a mortar that produces a few low results is penalised even if its average looks healthy.

 

In practice, that means consistency is assessed alongside strength. A mix that is strong on average, but erratic can still fail.

 

Flexural bond strength results (MPa)

 

Mortar systemChar. 7 dayChar. 29 dayAvg. 7 dayAvg. 29 day
M3 control (hydrated lime)0.2140.1550.3140.389
XLime (powder, recommended dose)0.4760.3650.5900.517
Liquid Lime (recommended 40 mL)0.2790.2760.3530.327
Liquid Lime (overdosed 60 mL)0.2210.1580.3630.280
MERCOL (pre-blended)0.7180.8180.9091.146

Source: Think Brick Australia, Mortar Workability: Lime Replacement Testing (July 2026).* Char. = characteristic strength. AS 3700 minimum characteristic flexural bond strength: 0.20 MPa at 7 days.

What the results show

The traditional mix is less consistent than its reputation

The hydrated lime control passed at 7 days, just clearing the minimum at 0.214 MPa. At 29 days its characteristic value fell to 0.155 MPa, driven largely by one low result of 0.127 MPa, even though its average strength rose. The traditional mix is not weak, but it is variable.

 

Lime replacements perform well when dosed correctly

Both lime replacements cleared the minimum comfortably at the recommended dose. XLime recorded the higher values of the two, and Liquid Lime at its recommended dose was the most stable, with almost identical characteristic strength at both ages.

 

More additive is not more insurance

The overdosed Liquid Lime mix, at 50% above the recommended dose, fell from 0.221 MPa at 7 days to 0.158 MPa at 29 days, below the AS 3700 minimum. This is the clearest practical finding in the report. A heavier pour is a common site habit, and the testing shows it can turn a compliant product into a non-compliant wall.

 

MERCOL recorded the highest bond strength

MERCOL achieved the highest characteristic strengths of all systems tested: 0.718 MPa at 7 days and 0.818 MPa at 29 days, roughly 3.6 to 4 times the AS 3700 minimum. It was also the only mix whose characteristic strength increased between the two test dates. The report’s authors noted that this level of bond performance may suit applications that need high structural capacity, such as load-bearing masonry.

 

The report notes that, due to time constraints, the MERCOL batch was mixed by a different TAFE staff member, had more water added, and was noticeably more fluid than the other mortars. The authors state that this may explain the higher values, or that the composition of the pre-blended mortar may produce a stronger bond. The report also describes its findings as informative rather than prescriptive, as some procedures were conducted outside standardised laboratory conditions to reflect real site practice. We’d suggest that adding more water is likely to decrease strength in normal conditions, rather than the opposite.

 

What can be said with confidence is this: in an independent, NATA-tested program, MERCOL exceeded the AS 3700 flexural bond requirement by a wide margin at both test ages, and showed the least loss of characteristic strength over time.

The bigger lesson: most mortar problems are batching problems

The report’s recommendations return repeatedly to site practice. Liquid additives are often poured without a measuring cap or without regard to the recommended dose. Cement-to-sand ratios, batching methods and mixing times vary from crew to crew and from day to day. Each of these changes the mortar that ends up in the joint.

 

This is the case for factory batching. In a pre-blended mortar, the sand is screened and dried, and the cement and other constituents are weighed at the plant rather than estimated on site. The variables that caused the overdosed mix to fail are removed before the bag is opened. Water remains the one site variable, which is why it should always be added to the specified volume.

Practical takeaways for bricklayers and specifiers

  • Measure every dose. Use the dosage cap or a measuring jug for liquid additives. The overdose result shows how little margin there can be.
  • Don’t over-mix. Earlier phases linked prolonged mixing to reduced performance.
  • Check the specification. Mortars using lime replacement products are not listed in AS 3700 Table 11.1, so they are treated as modified mixtures. Confirm they are acceptable for the job.
  • Plan the clean-down. Some formulations with water-repellent properties are harder to remove from the brick face, so test the cleaning method on a sample area first.
  • Judge mortar on consistency, not just strength. Characteristic strength rewards mixes that perform the same way every time.

 

The full report, Mortar Workability: Lime Replacement Testing, is available from Think Brick Australia.*

 

Talk to MERCOL

MERCOL manufactures pre-blended mortar in Victoria, with 38 colours certified to AS 3700 Class M4 across our mortar range, and supplies Victoria, Tasmania, New South Wales and Queensland. If you are specifying mortar for structural or high-consequence brickwork, our team can help.

 

Download a technical data sheet | Get a quote or request colour samples

 

*Register for a Think Brick Australia account to receive complimentary access to all manuals and stay up to date with the latest technical guidance.

 

Share the Post: